Practice area

Breach of Contract, Demand Letters & AAA Arbitration vs. Litigation

Before anyone files anything, the forum decides the cost. A demand letter costs about $440; AAA arbitration administrative fees alone run $2,600 to $16,175; a court filing fee is $210 to $435.

  • Demand letter ~$440
  • AAA admin $2,600 – $16,175
  • Federal filing $405
  • Interest 5% – 12%

Step 1: the demand letter

A demand letter on attorney letterhead is the cheapest escalation: a flat fee of about $440 (range $350 – $600), no filing fee and a response window of one to three weeks. It works best when the debt is documented and the other side is solvent. It should state the amount, the contractual basis, the interest you are entitled to and a deadline.

Texas notice rule: under Tex. Fin. Code § 304.104, prejudgment interest generally starts on the earlier of 180 days after the defendant receives written notice of the claim or the date suit is filed. A dated demand letter starts that clock.

Step 2: does small claims fit?

Business small claims courts are fast and cheap, but each state caps what an entity can recover. Claims above the cap must go to a higher court or be reduced.

Business small claims caps
StateCap for business claims
California$6,250 (entities) / $12,500 (individuals)
New York$10,000 (NYC Commercial Claims) / $5,000 outside NYC
Texas$20,000 (Justice Court)
Florida$8,000 (County Court, excluding costs and interest)
Illinois$10,000
Delaware$25,000 (Justice of the Peace Court)
Massachusetts$7,000 (District Court / BMC)
Washington$5,000 (businesses) / $10,000 (natural persons)
New Jersey$5,000 (Small Claims; $5,001 – $20,000 Special Civil Part)
Georgia$15,000 (Magistrate Court)

Step 3: arbitration or court?

If the contract has a mandatory AAA arbitration clause, the choice is made. Otherwise compare administrative fees against court filing fees. AAA's Standard Fee Schedule charges an initial filing fee and a final fee once a hearing is scheduled:

AAA Commercial Arbitration administrative fees (Standard Fee Schedule)
Claim amountInitial filing feeFinal feeTotal admin fees
Less than $75,000$1,450$1,150$2,600
$75,000 to less than $150,000$2,375$1,825$4,200
$150,000 to less than $300,000$2,975$2,275$5,250
$300,000 to less than $500,000$4,825$4,175$9,000
$500,000 to less than $1,000,000$5,500$6,825$12,325
$1,000,000 to less than $10,000,000$7,700$8,475$16,175

These administrative fees exclude arbitrator compensation, which is billed separately at the arbitrator's hourly or daily rate. Claims of $500,000 and above also fall under AAA's Procedures for Large, Complex Commercial Disputes.

Court is cheaper to start: CA $435, NY $210 + $95 RJI, TX $350, FL $400, IL $300 – $380, DE $210, MA $290, WA $290, NJ $250, GA $218. Federal district court charges $405 (28 U.S.C. § 1914(a)), and diversity jurisdiction requires more than $75,000 in controversy plus complete diversity of citizenship.

Parties reviewing documents across a conference table

Use prejudgment interest as leverage

Unpaid balances grow. Where the contract is silent, statutes set the rate:

Statutory prejudgment interest on contract claims
StateRateStatute
California10% per year (if the contract is silent)Cal. Civ. Code § 3289(b) & § 3287(a)
New York9% per yearN.Y. CPLR § 5004 & § 5001(a)
TexasOCCC published rate (prime-based, 5% floor, 15% cap)Tex. Fin. Code § 304.003 / § 304.002
FloridaQuarterly CFO rate (NY Fed discount rate average + 400 bps)Fla. Stat. § 55.03 & § 687.01
Illinois5% per year (written instruments and accounts)815 ILCS 205/2
DelawareFederal Reserve discount rate + 5%6 Del. C. § 2301(a)
Massachusetts12% per year (simple)Mass. Gen. Laws c. 231, § 6C
Washington12% per year (liquidated claims)RCW 19.52.010 / RCW 36.18.020
New JerseyCourt discretion (no fixed contract statute)N.J. Ct. R. 4:42-11 (equitable analog)
Georgia7% per year (general) / up to 18% on commercial accountsO.C.G.A. § 13-6-13 & § 7-4-16

On an $85,000 invoice twelve months overdue, Massachusetts' 12% simple interest adds $10,200; New York's 9% adds $7,650. Putting that number in the demand letter often moves a debtor more than the principal does. Run your own claim through the dispute cost calculator.

Fee-shifting changes the math

Under the American rule each side pays its own lawyers. A prevailing-party attorney fee clause in the contract reverses that, making a strong claim far more expensive for the debtor to resist — and a weak one more dangerous to bring.

  • Copy of the contract and any arbitration, venue or fee clause
  • Invoices, payment history and written communications
  • Date payment was due and any notice already sent
  • Amount claimed, including interest
  • Whether you want a demand letter, a forum recommendation, or litigation counsel

Related guides and tools

Legist Law is a legal information, statutory fee benchmarking, and attorney-matching platform. Legist Law is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice or representation. Legal services are provided exclusively by independent, licensed attorneys admitted in the applicable jurisdiction. Use of calculators or submission of a project brief does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Know the number before you sign the engagement letter.

Benchmark your matter, then send one structured brief to independent licensed counsel for fixed-fee or capped proposals.